If you live in Safety Harbor, you already know the drill: you want a real New York slice, the kind with a crust that holds its shape when you fold it, and you don't want to drive to Brooklyn for it. Aldo's New York Pizza sits a few minutes down the road on Gulf To Bay Blvd in Clearwater, and we run delivery and pickup for Safety Harbor every day we're open.
Hand-tossed — the dough was mixed this morning
Every single pizza starts with our freshly prepared dough, topped with premium cheeses and our rich, flavorful secret sauce, then baked to crispy perfection. Nothing arrives at this shop pre-pressed or frozen into a disc. That's the whole reason people keep ordering, and it's why we hold a 4.4 out of 5 rating across .
The menu runs well past a plain cheese pie. There's Sicilian, thick and square-cut. There's veggie. There are white pizzas like the Broadway Veggie and the Broccoli Bianca, $14.99 through $22.99 depending on size. Gourmet pies — Alfredo, BBQ Chicken, Buffalo Chicken — run $14.99 through $23.99. Pick a size, pick a pie, and we'll toss it fresh.
Wings, Subs, Baked Ziti and Cannoli
Plenty of Safety Harbor orders aren't pizza at all. Our Italian kitchen does the baked pasta properlyBaked Ziti at $16.99Baked Cheese Ravioli at $14.99 — and the sides and extras do most of the work on a family order:
- Buffalo Wings, from $7.99 up to $29.99 for the big trays
- Calzones, $12.99 to $16.99
- Subs including Buffalo Chicken and the Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Turkey, $7.99 to $12.99
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap, $13.99
- Salads made fresh daily — Caesar $7.99 to $10.99, Antipasto and California $8.99 to $12.99
- Cannoli $4.99, or a 12″ Cinnamon Pecan Pie for $12.99
- Cans $1.40, bottled water $1.75, 2-liter bottles $5.00
That's the real list, with the real prices. Build a Friday night out of it — a couple of large pies, a tray of wings, an Antipasto Salad and a pecan pie — and you've fed the whole street.
What Safety Harbor customers say about the delivery
The thing we care most about on a delivery order is whether the food still tastes like it did when it left the oven. Two of our reviewers put it better than we could:
First time ordering. We did delivery. Amazing pizza. The dough is excellent, perfectly baked. The antipasta was great. The garlic knots were still warm when delivered.
Best NY pizza outside of NY!
With we can quote from, that's the pattern — the dough gets mentioned, and the food shows up hot. Owner Mohamed Farhat has built the shop around those two things.
Ordering from Safety Harbor
The fastest way to eat is to order online. Put your pie together, add the wings, pay, and pick a delivery or pickup time — and you'll see our exclusive offers before you check out, which you won't get reading a paper menu. If you'd rather see everything laid out first, browse the full menu and then come back and order.
We deliver to Safety Harbor and throughout Clearwater, and you're welcome to drive over and pick up instead — it's a short run down Gulf To Bay.
Aldo's New York Pizza
2862 Gulf To Bay Blvd, Clearwater, FL 33759
(727) 210-3343 · mrmoe7380@gmail.com
Mon–Thu 11 AM–10 PM · Fri–Sat 11 AM–11 PM · Sun 11 AM–10 PM