Clearwater has no shortage of places to buy a pizza. What it has fewer of is pizzerias where the dough is made on site, the sauce is a recipe and not a can, and the pie comes out of the oven the way it would in a New York neighborhood shop. Aldo's New York Pizza is a hand-tossed, New York-style pizzeria at 2862 Gulf To Bay Blvd, and we're happy to be judged on that standard.
Hand-tossed — the dough was mixed this morning
Every single pizza here starts with our freshly prepared dough, topped with premium cheeses and our rich, flavorful secret sauce, then baked to crispy perfection. That's the whole method, and it's the thing worth asking any pizzeria in town about. If the answer involves a frozen shell, you already know what the slice will taste like.
Beyond the classic cheese and pepperoni, the menu runs through Sicilian pizza, veggie pizza and white pies. The Broadway Veggie and Broccoli Bianca are both white pizzas at $14.99 through $22.99 depending on size. On the gourmet side there's Alfredo Pizza and BBQ Chicken at $15.99 through $23.99, and Buffalo Chicken at $14.99 through $22.99.
Wings, Subs, Baked Ziti and Cannoli
A pizzeria is only as good as the rest of its board, because somebody in the car always doesn't want pizza. Ours is built around handcrafted pizzas, Italian favorites and fresh salads made daily with carefully selected premium ingredients. Here's a slice of it, with real prices so you can plan dinner rather than guess:
- Baked Ziti — $16.99, and Baked Cheese Ravioli — $14.99
- Calzones — $12.99 through $16.99
- Buffalo Wings — from $7.99, up to $29.99 for the big order
- Antipasto Salad — $8.99 through $12.99; Caesar Salad — $7.99 through $10.99; California Salad — $8.99 through $12.99
- Subs including Buffalo Chicken and the Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Turkey — $7.99 through $12.99
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap — $13.99
- Cannoli — $4.99, and a 12″ Cinnamon Pecan Pie — $12.99
- Bottled water $1.75, cans $1.40, 2-liter bottles $5.00
The full menu is online, and you can put an order together and pay for it right from your phone — that's the fastest way to get a pie in the oven at a busy hour.
What 956 Clearwater neighbors say
We hold a 4.4 out of 5 rating from . Those are people from Clearwater and Safety Harbor who order again, which is the only review metric that really counts in this business.
Best NY pizza outside of NY!
First time ordering. We did delivery. Amazing pizza. The dough is excellent, perfectly baked. The antipasta was great. The garlic knots were still warm when delivered.
Garlic knots arriving warm is a small thing that tells you a lot about how a kitchen times a delivery order. We pay attention to it.
Delivery and pickup on Gulf To Bay Blvd
We deliver, and you're welcome to come grab it yourself. Either way the food is made to order at 2862 Gulf To Bay Blvd, right on the Clearwater–Safety Harbor stretch, so it isn't traveling far before it reaches your table. Owner Mohamed Farhat runs the shop, and exclusive offers show up for people who sign up online.
If you've been scrolling through pizza in Clearwater, FL and want to settle the question, order a plain cheese pie and a dozen wings. That combination tells you everything about a pizzeria in one sitting.
Questions about an order, a large catering tray or something on the menu? Call us at (727) 210-3343 or email mrmoe7380@gmail.com. We're at 2862 Gulf To Bay Blvd, Clearwater, FL 33759.